The legacy of nineteenth-century replicas for object cultural biographies: lessons in duplication from 1830s Fife

Citation

Foster S, Blackwell A & Goldberg M (2017) The legacy of nineteenth-century replicas for object cultural biographies: lessons in duplication from 1830s Fife. St Andrews Preservation Trust Annual Report and Year Book, 2016, pp. 43-60. http://www.standrewspreservationtrust.com/STAPTyearbooks/79-2016/index.htm

Abstract
This article was the first award winner of the Trust's Murray Prize for History awarded in 2015, and is reprinted in this Annual Report and Yearbook. Because of space limitations its first two illustrations have been omitted and there have been minor deletions to the text. © FOSTER, S.M., BLACKWELL, A. and GOLDBERG, M., 2014. First published in Journal of Victorian Culture, 19(2), pp. 137-160 (http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/13555502.2014.919079) and reproduced with permission. Abstract: The St Andrews Sarcophagus and Norrie's Law hoard are two of the most important surviving Pictish relics from early medieval Scotland. The entanglement of their later biographies is also of international significance in its own right. Soon after discovery in nineteenth-century Fife, both sets of objects were subject, in 1839, to an exceptionally precocious, documented programme of replication through the enlightened auspices of an under-appreciated antiquarian, George Buist. This well-evidenced case study highlights how and why replicas, things that are widely prevalent in Europe and beyond, are a ‘thick' and relatively unexplored seam of archaeological material culture that we ignore at our peril. These particular replications also offer new insights into the vision, intellectual and practical energies of early antiquarian societies, and their web of connections across Britain and Ireland.

Keywords
replication; St Andrews Sarcophagus; Norrie's Law hoard; George Buist

Journal
St Andrews Preservation Trust Annual Report and Year Book: Volume 2016

• Foster et al 2017 AAM - revision of Foster et al 2014 for St Andrews Pres Trust Yrbook.pdf