Sporadic democracy: Education, democracy and the question of inclusion

Citation

Biesta GJJ (2009) Sporadic democracy: Education, democracy and the question of inclusion. In: Katz M, Verducci S & Biesta G (eds.) Education, Democracy and the Moral Life. New York: Springer, pp. 101-112. http://www.springer.com/education/educational+philosophy/book/978-1-4020-8625-0

Abstract
In this paper I take up the question of the relationship between democracy and inclusion. I present the deliberative turn in democratic theory as an attempt to overcome ‘external exclusion’ and discuss Iris Young’s work as an attempt to overcome ‘internal exclusions.’ I argue that although attempts to make democracy more inclusive are laudable, they are ultimately based upon a colonial conception of democratisation, one in which inclusion is seen as a process where those who are already on the inside include others into their sphere. I use the work of Jacques Rancière to argue for an understanding of democratisation as the interruption of the existing political order from the outside in the name of equality. This can not only help us to think differently about the role of inclusion in democracy. It also urges us to see that there are opportunities for the democratisation of education that lie beyond the inclusion of ‘newcomers’ into the existing democratic order.

Keywords
democracy; education; democratic education; citizenship education inclusion; ranciere; democratisation; Democracy and education; Learning, Psychology of; curriculum planning Scotland; Moral education