Understanding what asthma plans mean: a linguistic analysis of terminology used in published texts

Citation

Ring NA, Pinnock H, Wilson C, Hoskins G, Jepson R, Wyke S & Sheikh A (2011) Understanding what asthma plans mean: a linguistic analysis of terminology used in published texts. Primary Care Respiratory Journal, 20 (2), pp. 170-177. https://doi.org/10.4104/pcrj.2011.00012

Abstract
AIM: To identify from the literature what terms are used for 'asthma plans', with what meaning, and in what context(s). METHODS: Linguistic analysis of a selected body of asthma literature from 1989-2009. RESULTS: A wide range of asthma plan terminology was evident, with terms such as 'action plans', 'self-management plans' and 'treatment plans' being applied inconsistently and synonymously. For individual patients the term 'asthma plan' can describe a clinically-determined list of prescribed medication, an agreed plan to guide self-management of changing symptoms, or a more holistic 'living with asthma' plan. In some contexts the term 'asthma plan' was also used to describe an organisational system of care, which causes further ambiguity. CONCLUSIONS: Within the literature, a plethora of terms is used inconsistently and with varied meaning. This is a potential, but previously unrecognised, barrier to asthma plan implementation. A taxonomy of asthma plans and a standardised definitions of terms is required.

Keywords
asthma; action plans; self-management plans; terminology; meaning; linguistic analysis

Journal
Primary Care Respiratory Journal: Volume 20, Issue 2