Collapsing self/other positions: identification through differentiation

Citation

Gillespie A (2007) Collapsing self/other positions: identification through differentiation. British Journal of Social Psychology, 46 (3), pp. 579-595. https://doi.org/10.1348/014466606X155439

Abstract
There is a widely recognised tendency for people to positively differentiate Self from Other. The present paper asks: What counter dynamic constrains this othering tendency? A phenomenon, termed identification through differentiation is presented in which the positive differentiation of Self from Other collapses in a moment of identification. This phenomenon is demonstrated and explored using quasi-naturalistic group discussions with tourists in India. Three excerpts are analysed. The first demonstrates a tourist’s attempt to positively differentiate himself from other tourists. The second demonstrates how such an effort can collapse in a moment of identification with the previously derogated ‘other’ tourists. The third is used to explore how identification through differentiation is complicated by issues of self-presentation. The discussion uses concepts from Mead (1934) and Ichheiser (1949) in order to theorise about the preconditions, interactional mechanisms and wider applicability of the phenomenon.

Keywords
Self; Other; Identity; Tourists; Tourists India Psychological aspects; Identity (Psychology); Self-perception

Journal
British Journal of Social Psychology: Volume 46, Issue 3