School Discipline, Educational Interest and Pupil Wisdom

Citation

MacAllister J (2013) School Discipline, Educational Interest and Pupil Wisdom. Educational Philosophy and Theory, 45 (1), pp. 20-35. https://doi.org/10.1080/00131857.2012.711902

Abstract
In this article, the concept of school discipline will be explored in relation to that of educational interest. Initially, Clark’s account of two different kinds of school order (discipline and control) will be explained. The interest-based theory of school discipline advanced by Pat Wilson will thereafter be analysed. It will be argued that both these scholars persuasively explain how school discipline may follow when learning activities are successfully married to pupil interests and experiences. However, it will be maintained that the epistemic position adopted by Wilson is problematic. Although Wilson suggests that Richard Peters placed too great an educational emphasis on initiating pupils into public traditions of knowledge, it is here claimed that Wilson did not value that development enough. With reference to Whitehead, it is concluded that discipline in schools ought to be arranged so as to help pupils foster wisdom for life, as this concept integrates liberal knowledge and educational interest.

Keywords
discipline; control; wisdom; knowledge; School discipline; Deviant behavior

Journal
Educational Philosophy and Theory: Volume 45, Issue 1