Meaningful participation or tokenism for individuals on community based compulsory treatment orders? Views and experiences of the mental health tribunal in Scotland

Citation

Macgregor A (2022) Meaningful participation or tokenism for individuals on community based compulsory treatment orders? Views and experiences of the mental health tribunal in Scotland. Journal of Mental Health, 31 (2), pp. 158-165. https://doi.org/10.1080/09638237.2020.1818708

Abstract
Background The Mental Health (Care and Treatment) (Scotland) Act 2003 was considered as world leading when it was enacted due to its rights-based approach. Changes were made to encourage participation and enhance autonomy, including the Mental Health Tribunal for Scotland (the tribunal) replacing the Sheriff Court in making decisions about compulsory treatment. Aims To explore the views of individuals on community based compulsory treatment orders (CCTOs) and independent advocates to assess whether participation in the tribunal is perceived as meaningful in practice. Method A qualitative research design was adopted and semi-structured interviews were undertaken with 19 people with experience of being on a CCTO and eight mental health advocates in Scotland. The data were thematically analysed and explored using ethics of care principles. Results Individuals faced barriers to participation, including mental distress, medication, and inaccessible communication, and both the tribunal process and outcome were important in shaping perceptions of fairness. A perceived unsuccessful outcome was found to undermine an ostensibly participatory process, and unequal power dynamics resulted in feelings of powerlessness. Conclusions The findings suggest that participation is often experienced as tokenistic in practice and that cultural change is required if people are to be meaningfully involved in tribunal proceedings.

Keywords
Mental health tribunals; community-based compulsory treatment orders; participation; rights

Journal
Journal of Mental Health: Volume 31, Issue 2

• Published version