Nurses' perception of senior managers at the front line: people working with clipboards

Citation

Hoyle L (2014) Nurses' perception of senior managers at the front line: people working with clipboards. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 70 (11), pp. 2528-2538. https://doi.org/10.1111/jan.12399

Abstract
Aim To provide an original perspective on front‐line nurses' perception of senior managers who are not nurses. Background A key element of new public management had been the drive for ‘hands‐on’ professional management within the UK National Health Service, meaning the employment of mangers with managerial experience but little or no healthcare experience. Design An interpretive qualitative study, based on a single case study design with semi‐structured interviews. Methods Semi‐structured interviews were carried out with 31 front‐line Scottish National Health Service nurses exploring their perceptions of the role of managers between July–September 2010. Results/Findings Nursing staff were often unsure of the responsibilities of managers and perceived that there were an unnecessarily high number of managers within the National Health Service. Nursing staff raised concerns over the non‐clinical background of managers, including their ability to understand the pressures faced at the front line. Conclusions The main reason for conflict between managers and nursing staff was their differing foci. Managers were seen to concentrate on decisions surrounding targets, audits and budgets with little consideration given to the impact of these decisions on patient care.

Keywords
adult nursing; case study research; management; policy; workforce issues;

Journal
Journal of Advanced Nursing: Volume 70, Issue 11

People

Dr Louise Hoyle

Senior Lecturer in Nursing, Health Sciences Stirling